Meaning and Lyrics of Size Too Small by Sufjan Stevens

“Size Too Small” by Sufjan Stevens is a song rich with emotional depth and introspective contemplation. Its lyrics explore themes of friendship, love, inadequacy, and reconciliation. Through poetic imagery and metaphor, Stevens delves into the complexities of human relationships, personal identity, and enduring bonds.

Verse 1 begins with the poignant line, “I was the best man in a size too small.” This line sets the stage for the overarching narrative of the song. Being the “best man” suggests a role of significant importance, possibly at a wedding, while “in a size too small” indicates a sense of discomfort or inadequacy. It could symbolize the narrator’s feelings of not quite fitting into the role expected of him, whether literally in clothing or metaphorically in a relationship or societal role.

“You were my best friend, going at it all” introduces a deep and enduring friendship. The phrase “going at it all” might imply that this friend is facing life’s challenges head-on, possibly with confidence and vigor. The companionship and support in this friendship are evident, providing a foundation for the song’s emotional exploration.

The line, “What if I put off my inheritance?” introduces an element of sacrifice or postponement of personal gain. Inheritance could symbolize not just material wealth but also personal growth or legacy. The rhetorical question suggests a deeper contemplation about what the narrator might forego for the sake of this relationship.

“Where is the best man?” adds a note of uncertainty or searching. It’s as if the narrator is questioning his own role or place within the context of his friend’s life. The closing line of the verse, “All arise us all in peace,” can be interpreted as a hope or prayer for collective harmony and resolution, extending beyond the individuals to a broader sense of unity.

The Chorus reinforces the bond between the narrator and his friend. “I still know you, And I still like you, the best man” speaks of a lasting recognition and affection. Despite any discomfort or changes over time, the narrator’s feelings remain steadfast. “I still owe you” hints at a debt of gratitude or an unfulfilled promise, adding a layer of responsibility or unresolved sentiments.

Verse 2 continues to explore the themes of growth and change with “Everything rises, going at it all, All the surprises in a size too small.” Life’s progress and unexpected events are inevitable, yet they often come with challenges that feel overwhelming or ill-fitting. The repetition of the concept of “a size too small” underscores the persistent feeling of inadequacy or misalignment.

The narrator’s admission, “And what if I told you I was still in love with this?” brings a confession of enduring affection or commitment. “This” could refer to the relationship, the friendship, or a moment in time. The question invites the listener to consider how the friend might react to this revelation.

“Would you surprise us in a size for all of me?” This line suggests a yearning for acceptance and understanding. The narrator wonders if the friend could adapt or grow to accommodate all aspects of his being, despite any perceived inadequacies.

The Chorus repetition in the second verse reiterates the ongoing connection and unresolved emotions between the narrator and his friend. By stating, “I still know you, the best man, I still owe you,” the narrator reaffirms his enduring bond and sense of obligation.

Overall, “Size Too Small” is a reflective and deeply personal song that conveys the complexities of navigating significant relationships. Sufjan Stevens masterfully uses imagery and metaphor to express feelings of inadequacy, longing, and the enduring impact of true friendship. The repeated motifs and questions throughout the song invite listeners to ponder their own relationships and the ways in which they fit—or fail to fit—into the roles life assigns them.